Table 5 Data extraction questions
1. | What is the research question? |
2. | How were consultations selected? |
3. | Who were the population of interest? |
4. | How many consultations were videotaped? How many were analysed? |
5. | What methods have been used for analysis of the consultation? |
6. | Has the visual data been analysed? |
7. | Who was subsequently shown the videotapes? (patient or GP) |
8. | How many interviews were conducted? |
9. | How were the videotapes in the interviews selected? |
10. | What format did the interview take? (i.e. how the video playback was incorporated in the interview) |
11. | What was the analysis method of the interviews? |
12. | Has the researcher commented on the acceptability of the research method to participants? |
13. | To what extent did each element of data collection contribute to the findings? |
14. | What are the main findings? |
15. | What are the authors’ main conclusions? |
16. | What are the reviewer’s main conclusions? |
17. | Did each component (interview vs video) contribute to the findings? |
18. | To what extent did the VSR interview add to the research findings? |