Skip to main content

Table 3 Scaled domain scores (%)* derived from three testers, as per AGREE II scoring rubric[15]

From: Efficient clinical evaluation of guideline quality: development and testing of a new tool

 

Domain1

Domain2

Domain3

Domain4

Domain5

Domain6

AANN and ARN Clinical Practice Guideline [23]

66.7

64.8

45.8

77.8

9.7

41.7

Barbosa (Eastern Association of the Surgery of Trauma) [24]

81.5

29.6

49.3

75.9

27.8

36.1

Brain Trauma Foundation [25]

92.6

57.4

89.6

92.6

26.4

80.6

NICE [27]

98.1

92.6

94.4

92.6

48.6

83.3

SIGN [28]

98.1

100.0

100.0

96.3

95.8

88.9

Golisz [26]

100.0

61.1

76.4

90.7

51.4

22.2

  1. *NB The % domain scores have no measure of variance.