Table 2 Mean overall rating scores for AGREE II and the MiChe
From: Validation and reliability of a guideline appraisal mini-checklist for daily practice use
Guideline | AGREE II | MiChe | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Title/Leading Organization (Abbreviation) | Year of publication/pages/region/language | Topic | Overall quality | Recommendation for use | Overall quality [mean (SD)] | Recommendation for use [%] | Mean duration of appraisal [minutes] |
DEGAM Leitlinie Nr. 9, Herzinsuffizienz [Guideline no. 9 cardiac failure]/Deutsche Gesellschaft für Allgemeinmedizin und Familienmedizin (DEGAM 2006) [34] | 2006/278/GER/German | Cardiac failure | 6 | Yes | 6.7 (0.65) | Yes: 92 | 12.1 |
Yes, with certain reservations: 8 | |||||||
No: 0 | |||||||
Guideline for the Management of Acute Bronchitis/Alberta | 2008/6/CDN/English | Bronchitis | 3 | Yes, with modifications | 2.5 (1.20) | Yes: 17 | 9.7 |
Yes, with certain reservations: 33 | |||||||
Clinical Practice Guideline Working Group (ACPG 2008) [40] | No: 50 | ||||||
Diabetes und Schwangerschaft [Diabetes and pregnancy]/Deutschen Diabetes-Gesellschaft (DDG 2008) [36] | 2008/62/GER/German | Diabetes in pregnancy | 3 | Yes, with modifications | 4.9 (1.31) | Yes: 67 | 11.2 |
Yes, with certain reservations: 33 | |||||||
No: 0 | |||||||
Suspected cancer in primary care: Guidelines for investigation, referral and reducing ethnic disparities/New Zealand Guidelines Group (NZGG 2009) [38] | 2009/190/NZ/English | Cancer | 4 | Yes, with modifications | 4.3 (1.15) | Yes: 8.3 | 16.8 |
Yes, with certain reservations: 83.3 | |||||||
No: 8.3 | |||||||
Guidelines for the practice of diabetes self-management education/American Association of Diabetes Educators (AADE 2010) [41] | 2010/46/USA/English | Diabetes | 4 | Yes, with modifications | 2.8 (1.10) | Yes: 75 | 20.1 |
Yes, with certain reservations: 17 | |||||||
No: 8 | |||||||
Nebennierenrinden-Insuffizienz [Suprarenal gland failure]/Deutschen Gesellschaft für Endokrinologie; Gesellschaft für Kinderheilkunde und Jugendmedizin (DGKJ 2010) [42] | 2010/4/GER/German | Suprarenal gland failure | 2 | No | 1.8 (1.11) | Yes: 8 | 6.8 |
Yes, with certain reservations: 17 | |||||||
No: 75 | |||||||
Leitlinie Management der frühen rheumatoiden Arthritis [Guideline managment of early rheumatoid arthritis]/Deutsche Gesellschaft für Rheumatologie (DGR 2011) [37] | 2011/163/GER/German | Rheumatoid arthritis | 5 | Yes | 6.7 (0.65) | Yes: 100 | 13.3 |
Yes, with certain reservations: 0 | |||||||
No: 0 | |||||||
Aszites, spontan bakterielle Peritonitis, hepatorenales Syndrom [Ascites, spontaneous bacterial peritonitis, hepatorenal syndrome]/Deutsche Gesellschaft für Verdauungs- undStoffwechselkrankheiten (DGVS 2011) [33] | 2011/39/GER/German | Renal failure | 5 | Yes | 6.3 (0.90) | Yes: 92 | 14.1 |
Yes, with certain reservations: 8 | |||||||
No: 0 | |||||||
Leitlinie Management der frühen rheumatoiden Arthritis [Guideline managment of early rheumatoid arthritis]/Deutsche Gesellschaft für Rheumatologie (DGR 2011) [37] | 2011/163/GER/German | Rheumatoid arthritis | 5 | Yes | 6.7 (0.65) | Yes: 100 | 13.3 |
Yes, with certain reservations: 0 | |||||||
No: 0 | |||||||
Fieber unklarer Genese [Fever of unknown origin]/Gesellschaft für Kinder- und Jugendrheumatologie Deutschen Gesellschaft für Kinder- und Jugendmedizin (DGKJ 2013) [39] | 2013/8/GER/German | Fever | 2 | No | 2.4 (1.00) | Yes: 8 | 6.8 |
Yes, with certain reservations: 17 | |||||||
No: 75 | |||||||
Assessment and Management of Foot Ulcers for People with Diabetes/Registered Nurses’ Association of Ontario (RNAO 2013) [35] | 2013/160/USA/English | Diabetic foot lesions | 5 | Yes | 5.5 (1.31) | Yes: 67 | 18.2 |
Yes, with certain reservations: 33 | |||||||
No: 0 | |||||||