Table 1 Profiling of the studies

Doan et al. [12]

R

S

G&S

B

English

D

Denny et al. [9] and Denny et al. [10]

R

P

G&S

B

English

H,Phy

Denny et al. [11]

R

S

G&S

B

English

D,P

Edinger et al. [14]

R

P

G

E

English

D,R,N

Hsu et al. [18]

R

S

G&S

B

English

Pat,R

Kropf et al. [25]

R

S

G&S

E

German

Pat

Lee and Choi [27]

R

P

G

B

Korean

D

Lin et al. [30]

R

S

G

E

English

C,Pat

Mehrabi et al. [34]

R

S

G&S

E

English

C

Melton et al. [35]

R

P

G&S

E

English

O

Meystre and Haug [36]

R

S

G

E

English

NS

Taira et al. [55]

R

P

G

B

English

R

Phuong and Chau [42]

R

S

G

E

English

D

Rubin and Desser [45]

R

S

G

E

English

R

Schadow and McDonald [49]

R

S

G&S

E

English

Pat

Schuemie et al. [50]

R

P

G&S

E

English

C

Shivade et al. [51]

R

S

G&S

B

English

D,A,L

Singh et al. [52]

R

S

G

E

English

R

Suominen et al. [54]

R

S

G

E

Finish

D,A,P,N

Tran et al. [58]

R

P

G&S

B

English

NS

Wang et al. [60]

R

S

G

E

English

D

Xu et al. [65]

R

S

G

E

English

D

Bramsen et al. [3]

ML

P

G

I

English

D

Deléger and Névéol [8]

ML

S

G

I

French

NS

Haug et al. [17]

ML

P

G

B

English

D,O,C,Pat,R,H,Phy

Jancsary et al. [20] and Jancsary [21]

H

P

G&S

E

German

Dic

Li et al. [29]

ML

P

G

B

English

D,A,C

Lohr et al. [31]

ML

P

G&S

B

German

D

Mowery et al. [39]

ML

P

G&S

B

English

E

Tepper et al. [57]

ML

P

G&S

B

English

D,R

Waranusast et al. [62]

ML

P

G

I

Other

C

Apostolova et al. [1]

H

P

G

B

English

R

Cho et al. [6]

H

P

G&S

B

English

R,U

Dai et al. [7], Chen et al. [5]

H

P

G

B

English

D,O

Ganesan and Subotin [16]

H

P

G

E

English

NS

Ni et al. [40]

H

P

G&S

E

NS

NS

Sadoughi et al. [46]

H

P

G

B

English

Dic