Skip to main content

Table 1 Decision maker factors

From: When piloting health services interventions, what predicts real world behaviours? A systematic concept mapping review

Factor

Definition

Association with consistency

Type of supporting data

Age

Age of the decision-maker

Older decision makers show more consistency between hypothetical and real life decisions

Empirical [30]

Education

Educational attainment of the decision-maker

More educated decision makers show more consistency between hypothetical and real decisions

Empirical [30]

Cognitive Control

The decision-makers use of mental processes to concentrate and think

Higher cognitive control is correlated to inconsistency between hypothetical decisions and real decisions

Empirical [23]

Cognitive Ability

Cognitive ability of the decision-maker

Higher cognitive ability increases risk aversion for hypothetical decisions but not for real life ones

Empirical [25]

Thinking Dispositions

Whether decision-makers have dispositions about thinking that allow them to accept strategies to make hypothetical reasoning resemble real-world reasoning

Being in a state of prolonged doubt increases correlation between hypothetical and real life decisions

Hypothesis [21]

Openness to Experience

Measure of the decision-maker’s openness to a variety of ideas and experiences

Greater openness to experience trait (IASR-B5) is predictive of hypothetical decisions but not real ones

Empirical [31, 32]

Other Personality Traits

Personality traits, other than openness to experience, of the decision-maker

Personality traits, especially extraversion low neuroticism, and anti-social traits correlated with inconsistently between hypothetical and real life decisions

Empirical [13, 32,33,34]