Skip to main content

Table 2 Analysis of the included N-CPGs according to AGREE II (%)

From: An exploration of how developers use qualitative evidence: content analysis and critical appraisal of guidelines

Guidelines Scope and purpose Stakeholder involvement Rigour of development Clarity of presentation Applicability Editorial independence
1 83 64 74 72 63 96
2 83 67 74 72 63 96
3 83 67 74 72 63 79
4 83 67 74 72 63 79
5 78 67 74 72 63 96
6 83 67 74 72 63 96
7 83 67 74 72 63 96
8 83 67 74 72 63 79
9 83 67 74 72 63 96
10 78 67 74 72 63 96
11 78 67 74 72 63 96
12 78 69 74 72 63 96
13 83 64 74 72 60 96
14 83 69 74 72 60 96
15 89 86 78 78 77 79
16 83 83 78 78 77 79
17 86 75 80 78 73 79
18 83 83 78 75 81 79
19 83 81 79 78 73 79
20 86 78 79 75 77 79
21 89 86 78 728 73 79
22 83 81 78 78 79 79
23 86 81 77 72 75 75
24 86 86 78 72 73 79
25 86 83. 76 78 73 79
26 72 78 65 72 60 88
27 78 67 69 47 67 75
28 83 67 69 58 67 75
29 83 67 69 58 67 75
30 83 67 69 58 67 75
31 83 67 71 58 67 75
32 83 67 69 42 67 75
33 83 67 71 58 67 75
34 83 67 71 58 67 75
35 83 67 69 58 67 75
36 83 67 69 58 67 75
37 83 67 69 47 67 75
38 83 67 71 47 67 75
39 83 67 71 58 67 75
40 83 67 69 58 67 75
41 83 67 71 58 67 75
42 83 67 69 47 67 75
43 78 78 82 83 81 75
44 83 78 61 86 75 54
45 92 86 82 78 81 88
46 86 78 50 81 75 63
47 86 86 78 83 85 92
48 83 64 78 81 71 88
49 81 81 70 81 75 58
50 81 86 78 78 71 54
51 64 47 59 75 19 79
52 78 56 18 47 21 4
53 64 67 72 67 75 79
54 58 69 50 78 33 83
55 61 58 35 58 15 0
56 67 50 20 50 67 13
57 72 42 44 81 48 0
58 72 36 61 81 60 0
59 75 81 72 72 60 83
60 81 31 71 75 58 29
61 64 81 56 64 56 0
62 50 61 11 50 8 0
63 69 47 49 67 44 83
64 58 44 59 61 31 0
Median, interquartile range (25, 75%) 83 (78, 83) 67 (67, 78) 71(69, 74) 72 (58, 78) 67(63, 73) 79(75, 83)