Skip to main content

Table 4 Reported intra-cluster correlation coefficients for primary outcomes (N = 26)

From: Characteristics and practices of school-based cluster randomised controlled trials for improving health outcomes in pupils in the United Kingdom: a methodological systematic review

Author

Year

Cluster unit

Outcome

Health area

Outcome type

ICC estimate

Stallard [53]

2012

year group

Symptoms of low mood (depression)

socioemotional function

continuous

0.012

Chisholm [22]

2016

class

Stigma of mental illness

socioemotional function

continuous

0.1

Obsuth [71]

2017

school

School exclusion

socioemotional function

binary

0.028

Connolly [82]

2018

school

Prosocial behaviour

socioemotional function

continuous

0.116

Ford [32]

2019

school

Mental health / behaviour

socioemotional function

continuous

0.121

Axford [44]

2020

school

Victimisation (being bullied) occurring at least twice a month in the last 2 months

socioemotional function

binary

0.019

Campbell [26]

2008

school

Smoking in the past week

smoking

binary

0.017

Conner [74]

2019

school

Ever smoking

smoking

binary

0.017

McKay [24]

2018

school

Heavy episodic drinking in the previous 30 days (> = 6 units for males and >  = 4.5 units for females)

alcohol misuse

binary

0.121

Croker [40]

2012

school

Child's eating habits

obesity

continuous

0.07

Fairclough [56]

2013

school

Waist circumference (cm)

obesity

continuous

0.06

Lloyd [57]

2018

school

BMI z score

obesity

continuous

0.014

Breheny [43]

2020

school

BMI z-score at 12 months

obesity

continuous

0.001

Jago [41]

2015

school

Mean weekday minutes of moderate to vigorous physical activity per day

physical activity

continuous

0.0005

Harrington [58]

2018

school

Minutes per day of moderate- to vigorous physical activity

physical activity

continuous

0.02

Norris [67]

2018

school

Sedentary behaviour during the school day in minutes

physical activity

continuous

0.080

Jamesa [28]

2004

class

Consumption of carbonated drinks over 3 days (in glasses)

nutrition

continuous

-0.009

Christian [25]

2014

school

Combined daily fruit and vegetable intake (grams per day)

nutrition

continuous

0.003

Redmond [81]

1999

school

Proportion of teeth sites with caries at 6 months

dental health

continuous

0.16

Worthington [31]

2001

school

Plaque score

dental health

continuous

0.023

Milsom [59]

2006

school

Whether the child has active caries in their first permanent molars

dental health

binary

0.027

Mulvaney [68]

2006

school

Use of visibility aid (reflective and fluorescent slap wrap) while cycling

injury

binary

0.21

Kendrick [79]

2007

school

Knowledge score for fire and burn prevention

safety

continuous

0.187

Hubbard [76]

2016

school

Number of recognised cancer warning signs

cancer

continuous

0.038

Henderson [27]

2007

school

Terminations of pregnancy by age 20

obstetrics

count

0.005

Giles [23]

2014

school

Intention to breastfeed

obstetrics

continuous

0.12

  1. aThe estimated intra-cluster correlation coefficient in James (2004) was negative. True negative values are generally considered implausible in the context of cluster randomised trials