More than one third of clinical practice guidelines on low back pain overlap in AGREE II appraisals. Research wasted?

Gianola, Silvia; Bargeri, Silvia; Cinquini, Michela; Iannicelli, Valerio; Meroni, Roberto; Castellini, Greta

doi:10.1186/s12874-022-01621-w

Table 2 Overlapping CPGs for LBP

From: More than one third of clinical practice guidelines on low back pain overlap in AGREE II appraisals. Research wasted?

	No. of CPGs (out of 106)	%	ORGANISATION ACRONYM	YEAR	COUNTRY	AUTHOR
Overlapping 9 times	1	0.9	NICE	2016	UK	Arvin and De campos [63]
Overlapping 8 times	2	1.9	ACP	2017	USA	Qaseem[47]
Overlapping 8 times	2	1.9	APTA	2012	USA	Delitto [56]
Overlapping 7 times	0	0.0	-	-	-	-
Overlapping 6 times	1	0.9	KCE	2017	Belgium	van Wambeke [43]
Overlapping 5 times	2	1.9	APS	2009	USA	Chou [65]
Overlapping 5 times	2	1.9	CCGPP	2016	USA	Globe [55]
Overlapping 4 times	4	3.8	ASIPP	2013	USA	Manchikanti [49]
			KNGF	2013	Netherlands	Staal [46]
			TOP	2017	Canada	Low Back Pain Working Group [53]
			VA/DoD	2017	USA	Pangarkar [48]
Overlapping 3 times	13	12.3	CAAM	2016	China	Zhao [42]
			CCGI	2018	Canada	Bussières [60]
			Cheng	2012	JAPAN	Cheng [59]
			DAI	2017	Germany	Chenot [58]
			DHA	2017	Denmark	Stochkendahl [45]
			ICSI	2012	USA	Goertz [54]
			ICSI	2018	USA	Thorson [44]
			NASS	2013	USA	Kreiner [50]
			NASS	2014	USA	Kreiner [51]
			NICE	2009	UK	Savigny [64]
			OMG	2012	Canada	Brosseau L[61]
			PSP	2017	Poland	Kassolik [52]
			SIGN	2013	UK	NR [62]
Overlapping 2 times	20	18.9	ACOEM	2019	USA	Hegmann [66]
			ACOEM	2016	USA	Hegmann[67]
			ACR	2016	USA	Patel [68]
			AOA	2016	USA	Task Force on the Low Back Pain Clinical Practice Guidelines [69]
			APS	2007	USA	Chou [70]
			BPS	2013	UK	Lee [71]
			DSA	2016	Netherlands	Itz [72]
			-	2006	Europe	Airaksinen [73]
			Institute of Medicine	2019	USA	Deer [74]
			KIOM	2017	Korea	Jun [75]
			NASS	2012	USA	Kreiner [76]
			NASS	2014	USA	Kreiner [77]
			NASS	2016	USA	Matz [78]
			NVL	2017	Germany	Bundesärztekammer [79]
			PARM	2012	Philippine	NR [80]
			-	2016	Italy	Picelli [81]
			SOECGP	2011	USA	Livingstone [82]
			TOP	2015	Canada	TOP [83]
			TOP	2009	Canada	TOP [84]
			University of Michigan	2011	USA	Chiodo [85]
Overall (>=2)	43	40.6

ACOEM American College of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, ACP American College of Physicians, ACR American College of Radiology, AOA American Osteopathic Association, APS American Pain Society, APTA American Physical Therapy Association, ASIPP American Society of Interventional Pain Physicians, BPS British Pain Society, CAAM China Association of Acupuncture-Moxibustion, CCGI Canadian Chiropractic Guideline Initiative, CCGPP Council on Chiropractic Guidelines and Practice Parameters, DAI Deutsches Ärzteblatt International, DHA Danish Health Authority, DSA Dutch Society of Anesthesiologists, ICSI Institute for Clinical Systems Improvement, KCE Belgian Health Care Knowledge Centre, KIOM Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine, KNGF Koninklijk Nederlands Genootschap voor Fysiotherapie, NASS North American Spine Society, NICE National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, NVL Nationale Versorgungs Leitlinie, OMG Ottawa Methods Group, PARM Philippine Academy of Rehabilitation Medicine, PSP Polish Society of Physiotherapy, SIGN Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network, SOEGCP State of Oregon Evidence-based Clinical Guidelines Project, TOP Toward Optimized Practice Low Back Pain Working Group, VADoD Veterans Affairs/Department of Defense Collaboration Office

Back to article page

ISSN: 1471-2288

Contact us

General enquiries: journalsubmissions@springernature.com

BMC Medical Research Methodology

Contact us