Skip to main content

Table 2 Baseline characteristics of the overall study population, as well as the subgroups of patients unmatched and matched within different calipers

From: Impact of methodological choices in comparative effectiveness studies: application in natalizumab versus fingolimod comparison among patients with multiple sclerosis

 

Overall

Matching with caliper = 0.1

Matching with caliper = 0.2

Matching with caliper = 0.02

ALL

Matched

Excluded

Matched

Excluded

Matched

Excluded

N = 5148

N = 3258

N = 1890

N = 3278

N = 1870

N = 3232

N = 1916

Sexa

  Female

3698 (72%)

2342 (72%)

1356 (72%)

2352 (72%)

1346 (72%)

2332 (72%)

1366 (71%)

  Male

1450 (28%)

916 (28%)

534 (28%)

926 (28%)

524 (28%)

900 (28%)

550 (29%)

Age at treatment startb

37.7 (30.1–44.7)

37.3 (30.1–44.3)

38.5 (31.8–45.6)

37.2 (30.1–44.4)

38.7 (31.8–45.4)

37.4 (30.2–44.5)

38.3 (31.5–45.1)

MS duration at treatment startb

6.9 (3.1–12.5)

6.4 (2.7–2.0)

7.9 (4.0–13.4)

6.4 (2.6–2.0)

7.9 (4.0–13.4)

6.3 (2.6–12.0)

8.1 (4.0–13.3)

EDSS at treatment starta

  Less than 2

1556 (30%)

782 (24%)

774 (41%)

810 (25%)

746 (40%)

789 (24%)

767 (40%)

  Between 2 and 3.5

2384 (46%)

1609 (49%)

775 (41%)

1593 (49%)

791 (42%)

1588 (49%)

796 (42%)

  4 or more

1208 (23%)

867 (27%)

341 (18%)

875 (27%)

33 (18%)

855 (26%)

353 (18%)

Number of relapses in the previous 12 monthsa

  0

1857 (36%)

1063 (33%)

794 (42%)

1085 (33%)

772 (41%)

1059 (33%)

798 (42%)

  1

2021 (39%)

1290 (40%)

731 (39%)

1268 (39%)

753 (40%)

1276 (39%)

745 (39%)

  2

975 (19%)

690 (21%)

285 (15%)

707 (22%)

268 (14%)

696 (22%)

279 (15%)

  3 or more

295 (6%)

215 (7%)

80 (4%)

218 (7%)

77 (4%)

107 (7%)

94 (5%)

Number of previous MS treatmentsa

  0

836 (16%)

582 (18%)

254 (13%)

580 (18%)

256 (14%)

584 (18%)

252 (13%)

  1

2559 (50%)

1594 (49%)

965 (51%)

1597 (49%)

962 (51%)

1558 (48%)

1001 (52%)

  2

1187 (23%)

738 (23%)

449 (24%)

744 (23%)

443 (24%)

748 (23%)

439 (23%)

  3 or more

566 (11%)

344 (11%)

222 (12%)

357 (11%)

209 (11%)

342 (11%)

224 (12%)

MS activity in the previous 12 monthsa

  None

1438 (28%)

776 (24%)

662 (35%)

782 (24%)

656 (35%)

764 (24%)

674 (35%)

  Worsening

419 (8%)

287 (9%)

132 (7%)

303 (9%)

116 (6%)

295 (9%)

124 (6%)

  Relapse

2159 (42%)

1395 (43%)

764 (40%)

1398 (43%)

761 (41%)

1397 (43%)

762 (40%)

  Relapse and worsening

1132 (22%)

800 (25%)

332 (18%)

795 (24%)

337 (18%)

776 (24%)

356(19%)

Data sourcea

  MS Base

3293 (64%)

1874 (58%)

1419 (75%)

1882 (57%)

1411(75%)

1852 (57%)

1441 (75%)

  DMSR

1444 (28%)

1167 (36%)

277 (15%)

1179 (36%)

265 (14%)

1153 (36%)

291 (15%)

  OFSEP

411 (8%)

217 (7%)

194 (10%)

217 (7%)

194 (10%)

227 (7%)

184 (10%)

  1. aN (%)
  2. bMedian (Quartiles)