From: Improving the accuracy of self-reported height and weight in surveys: an experimental study
Version | Height question | Weight question | n | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Science Survey | ||||||
Science_a. (No preamble) | Science_b. I’m now going to ask you your height and weight. It’s very important that we get as accurate data on these questions as possible | Science_c. I’m now going to ask you your height and weight. Research shows that people tend to overestimate their height and underestimate their weight. It’s very important that we get as accurate data on these questions as possible | Science_Wa. How much do you weigh? (ONLY IF QUERIED: ‘Without clothes or shoes’) | Science_Wb. How much do you weigh without clothes or shoes? | ||
How tall are you without shoes? | Can you tell me, how tall are you without shoes? | Can you tell me, how tall are you without shoes? | ||||
Sci-1 | x | x | 172 | |||
Sci-2 | x | x | 190 | |||
Sci-3 | x | x | 224 | |||
Sci-4 | x | x | 217 | |||
Sci-5 | x | x | 200 | |||
Sci-6 | x | x | 171 | |||
EB Survey | ||||||
EB_a. (No preamble) | EB_b. I’m now going to ask you your height and weight. Please respond honestly. Our data rely on honest answers. Remember your name is not associated with your responses, so no one will know your height and weight | EB_c. I’m now going to ask you your height and weight. Research shows that people tend to OVERestimate their height and UNDERestimate their weight. It’s very important that we get as accurate data on these questions as possible | EB_Wa. How much do you weigh? (ONLY IF QUERIED: ‘Without clothes or shoes’) | EB_Wb. How much do you weigh without clothes or shoes? | ||
How tall are you without shoes? | Can you tell me, how tall are you without shoes? | Can you tell me, how tall are you without shoes? | ||||
EB-1 | x | x | 37 | |||
EB-2 | x | x | 38 | |||
EB-3 | x | x | 34 | |||
EB-4 | x | x | 26 | |||
EB-5 | x | x | 29 | |||
EB-6 | x | x | 36 |