Skip to main content

Table 1 Comparison of participation rates, ages and asthma outcomes between centres.

From: A methodology to establish a database to study gene environment interactions for childhood asthma

Centre

Number of children

Mean age (years)

Median SIMD decile

Mean % FEV1

Median FENO(SEM), ppb

Median BTS treatment step

 

Invited

Participated

Participants

Non participants

Participants

Non participants

   

Aberdeen

167

93

8.8 (4.1)

9.1 (4.3)

7

7

96 (17)

27 (6)

3

       

n = 41

n = 41

 

Dundee

220

91

8.1 (4.2)

9.0 (4.4)

6

5

100 (17)

25 (6)

3

       

n = 45

n = 44

 

Edinburgh

271

140

8.5 (4.1)

9.8 (4.3)

7

5

91 (11)

16 (4)

3

       

n = 38

n = 54

 

Elgin

70

29

8.9 (4.1)

9.8 (4.3)

6.5

5

103 (12)

17 (6)

3

       

n = 12

n = 9

 

Kirkcaldy

80

42

6.8 (3.3)

8.5 (3.6)

5

4

93 (14)

11 (18)

3

       

n = 9

n = 8

 

Melrose

24

17

11.1 (3.0)

10.5 (3.8)

7

5

93 (9)

14 (7)

3

       

n = 13

n = 15

 

Perth

119

45

10.0 (3.4)

9.8 (3.7)

6

7

104 (12)

41 (10)

3

       

n = 14

n = 14

 

Other

94

64

9.0 (4.3)

8.3 (4.3)

4

4

none

None

2.5

Overall

1045

501

8.6 (3.9)

9.2 (4.0)*

6 †

6

97 (15)†

18 (2)

3 (2, 3)†

  1. SIMD = Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation, SEM = Standard Error of Mean, BTS = British Thoracic Society.*p = 0.022 for comparison between participants and non participants. † p value for trend tests for %FEV1, SIMD decile and BTS severity between centres <0.05.