Skip to main content

Table 3 Feature Importance to the Definition of a CQI Initiative and Agreement between Panels

From: Conducting Online Expert panels: a feasibility and experimental replicability study

Features Panel A,
Phase I
Panel B,
Phase I
Panel C,
Phase I
Panel D,
Phase I
Total,
Phase I
Panel A,
Phase III
Panel B,
Phase III
Panel C,
Phase III
Panel D,
Phase III
Total,
Phase III
Feature 1 14
93.3%
.53
12
100%
.25
30
90.9%
.39
30
96.8%
.45
86
94.5%
.42
10
100%
.3
10
100%
.2
32
97%
.24
26
100%
.27
78
98.7%
.25
Feature 2 13
92.9%
.57
6
50%
.92
28
82.4%
.71
21
67.7%
.87
68
74.7%
.77
9
90%
.6
5
50%
.8
28
84.8%
.64
18
69.2%
.89
60
75.9%
.69
Feature 3 8
57.1%
1
5
41.7%
.92
20
58.8%
1.03
16
51.6%
.97
49
53.8%
1.01
5
50%
.8
1
10%
.3
19
59.4%
.91
16
59.3%
.85
41
51.9%
.94
Feature 4 13
92.9%
.5
6
50%
1.17
25
3.5%
7 .91
26
74.2%
.94
67
73.6%
.97
8
80%
.6
6
60%
.6
28
84.8%
.73
24
88.9%
.63
66
82.5%
.75
Feature 5 6
42.9%
1.14
7
58.3%
1.08
18
54.5%
1
19
61.3%
.68
50
55.6%
.94
5
50%
.8
7
70%
.8
23
71.9%
.69
15
55.6%
.59
50
63.3%
.68
Feature 6 11
84.6%
1.21
9
75%
.75
30
88.2%
.62
27
87.1%
.74
77
85.6%
.77
9
90%
.5
9
90%
.4
29
90.6%
.47
24
88.9%
.52
71
89.9%
.51
Feature 7 11
78.6%
1
9
75%
.58
27
79.4%
.68
28
90.3%
.55
75
82.4%
.67
8
80%
.9
9
90%
.5
25
75.8%
.73
26
96.3%
.52
68
85%
.65
Feature 8 6
46.2%
1.15
8
66.7%
.92
20
58.8%t
1.03
22
71%
.77
56
62.2%
.96
6
66.7%
.67
7
70%
.7
21
63.6%
.76
18
66.7%
.85
52
65.8%
.77
Feature 9 11
84.6%
.46
10
83.3%
.58
N/A 28
90.3%
.48
49
87.5%
.58
10
100%
.1
10
100%
.4
18
62.1%
.79
26
96.3%
.37
64
84.2%
.73
Feature 10 9
64.3%
1.07
6
50%
.92
14
41.2%
1.38
16
51.6%
1.23
45
49.5%
1.27
4
40%
1.2
3
30%
.6
9
28.1%
1.06
13
48.1%
1.48
29
36.7%
1.05
Feature 11 13
92.9%
.71
8
66.7%
1.17
22
75.9%
.83
23
74.2%
.84
66
76.7%
.92
10
100%
.5
6
60%
1
26
81.3%
.59
19
70.4%
.78
61
77.2%
.82
  1. (Frequencies, % of responses higher than 3 on a 1-5 importance scale, MAD-M)
  2. Question: How important is this feature to the definition of a CQI initiative? Response scale: 1 = Not Important - 5 = Very Important
  3. Cells with bold font indicate panels where the majority (> 66.6%) of participants think that this feature is important for the definition of CQI.