From: Tools used to assess the quality of peer review reports: a methodological systematic review
Journal or Company Name a | First Author, Year | Format | Quality defined b | Overall quality assessment | Items (n) | Items weights c | Scoring range d | Scoring system instruction e | Scale/ Checklist Development f | Validity g | Reliability h | Internal consistency | RCTs i |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Advances in Nursing Science; Issues in Mental Health Nursing; The Journal of Holistic Nursing | Shattell 2010 [33] | Scale | N | Summary Score | 6 | S | 1–10 | N | NR | NR | NR | NR | 0 |
American Journal of Roentgenology | Friedman 1995 [22] | Scale | N | Single Score | 1 | NA | 1–4 | N | NR | NR | NR | NR | 0 |
American Journal of Roentgenology | Kliewer 2005 [49] | Scale | N | Summary Score | 4 | NA | 1–4 | N | NR | NR | NR | NR | 0 |
American Journal of Roentgenology | Rajesh 2013 [32] | Scale | N | Single Score | 1 | NA | 1–4 | P | NR | NR | NR | NR | 0 |
American Journal of Roentgenology | Berquist 2017 [50] | Scale | N | Summary Score | 4 | NA | 0–4 | Y | NR | NR | NR | NR | 0 |
Annals of Emergency Medicine | Callaham 1998 [25] | Scale | N | Single Score | 1 | NA | 1–5 | N | NR | NR | Inter-Rater (ICC = 0.44, 0.24, 0.12) l | NR | 2 m |
Annals of Emergency Medicine | Scale | N | Summary Score | 6 | NA | 1–5 | N | NR | NR | Inter-Rater (ICC = 0.44, 0.24, 0.12) l | NR | 1 | |
Annals of Emergency Medicine; Annals of Internal Medicine; JAMA; Obstetrics & Gynecology and Ophthalmology | Justice 1998 [35] | Scale | N | Summary Score | 4 | S | 1–5 | N | NR | NR | NR | NR | 0 |
British Journal of General Practice | Moore 2014 [29] | Scale | N | Single Score | 1 | NA | A-E | Y | NR | NR | NR | 0 | |
British Medical Journal | Scale | N | Summary Score | 7 | S | 1–5 | N | Y | Face (N = 20) | Test-Retest (Kw = 1.00) | Internal Consistency (Cronbach’s alpha = 0.84) | 5 | |
Mean | Content (N = 20) Construct | Inter-Rater (Kw = 0.83) | |||||||||||
British Medical Journal | Van Rooyen 1999 (RQI 4) [27] | Scale | N | Mean n | 8 | S | 1–5 | N | NR | NR | Inter-Rater (Kw = 0.38–0.67) o | 2 | |
Chinese Journal of Tuberculosis and Respiratory Diseases | Yang 2009 [52] | Checklist | N | NA | 5 | NA | NA | N | NR | NR | NR | 0 | |
Journal of Clinical Investigation | Stossel 1985 [30] | Scale | N | Single Score | 1 | NA | Good- Fair- Poor | Y | NR | NR | NR | 0 | |
Journal of General Internal Medicine | Scale | N | Summary Score | 9 | S | 1–5 | N | NR | Construct | NR | 1 | ||
Journal of Vascular Interventional Radiology | Feurer 1994 [41] | Scale | N | Sum | 7 | D | 0–14 | N | NR | Content (N = 2) Preliminary Criterion (N = 2) (Kendall = 0.94) | Inter-Rater (ICC = 0.84) | 0 | |
NA | Review quality collector (RQC) 2012 [53] | Scale | N | Mean | 4 | User-defined weights | 0–100 | N | NR | NR | NR | 0 | |
Nursing Research | Henly 2009 [24] | Scale | N | Mean (CAS, GAS scale) | 15 | S | 1–5 | P | NR | NR | Inter-Rater (ICC = 0.79) p | 0 | |
Summary Score (OAS scale) | 1–5 | ||||||||||||
Summary Score (GRQ scale) | 0–100 | ||||||||||||
Nursing Research | Henly 2010 [36] | Scale | N | Mean (CAS, GAR, SARNR scale) | 26 | S | 1–5 | P | NR | NR | Inter-Rater (ICC = 0.75)p | 0 | |
Summary Score (GRQ scale) | 0–100 | ||||||||||||
Obstetrics & Gynecology, Dutch Journal of Medicine | Landkroon 2006 [42] | Scale | N | Summary Score | 5 | NA | 1–5 | Y | NR | NR | Test-Retest (ICC =0.66–0.88) Inter-Rater (ICC = 0.62) | 0 | |
Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences | Jawaid 2006 [34] | Scale | N | NR q | 5 | S | 1–5 | N | NR | NR | NR | 0 | |
Peerage of science | Peerage Essay Quality (PEQ) 2011 [37] | Scale | N | Mean | 3 | S | 1–5 | N | NR | NR | NR | 0 | |
Publons Academy | Review Rating and Feedback Form 2016 [38] | Scale | N | Sum | 4 | S | 0–3 (Full score: 0–12) | N | NR | NR | NR | 0 | |
The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery | Thompson 2016 [31] | Scale | N | Single Score | 1 | NA | 80–100 | Y | NR | NR | Inter-Rater (ICC = -4.5 to 0.99) r | 0 | |
The National Medical Journal of India | Das Sinha 1999 [54] | Scale | N | Sum | 5 | D | 0–100 | N | NR | NR | NR | 0 |