Skip to main content

Table 4 Mean of errors (me) / distance between index estimations and targets of estimation

From: Interrater reliability estimators tested against true interrater reliabilities

   

A.

B.

C.

D.

E.

F.

G.

1

Author or Source

%-agreement

Bennett et al.

Perreault & Leigh

Gwet

Scott

Cohen

Krippendorff

Interrater Reliability

2

Interrater Reliability Estimator

ao

S

Ir

AC1

Ï€

κ

α

3

me (ri) = mean (|ri-ori|) (0 ≤ me ≤ 1)

.130***

.096***

.180***

.093***

.327***

.324***

.323***

4

Standard Deviation of me (ri)

.145

.099

.148

.104

.221

.220

.220

5

95% confidence interval of me (ri)

.115 ~ .144

.086 ~ .106

.164 ~ .194

.082 ~ .103

.304 ~ .349

.302 ~ .346

.301 ~ .345

Chance Agreement

6

Chance Agreement Estimator

aoac

Sac

Irac

ACac

Ï€ac

κac

αac

7

me (ac):=mean (|ac-oac|) (0 ≤ me ≤ 1)

.130***

.182***

.182***

.130***

.450***

.448***

.448***

8

Standard Deviation of me (ac)

.145

.141

.141

.127

.201

.201

.202

9

95% confidence interval of me (ac)

.115 ~ .144

.168 ~ .196

.168 ~ .196

.117 ~ .143

.429 ~ .470

.428 ~ .469

.427 ~ .468

N

10

Nc (number of rating sessions)

384

384

384

384

384

384

384

11

Nd (number items within each session)

100

100

100

100

100

100

100

  1. *: p<.05, **: p<.01, ***: p<.001