Skip to main content

Table 5 Logistic regression models of consent to give blood, full sample, IP12

From: Does the feedback of blood results in observational studies influence response and consent? A randomised study of the Understanding Society Innovation Panel

 

Mode of final interview

Mode and feedback interaction

Participant characteristics

Time in study

All covariates

Characteristic

OR

95% CI

P

OR

95% CI

p

OR

95% CI

p

OR

95% CI

p

OR

95% CI

p

Feedback only, no covariates

1.38

1.16, 1.64

 < 0.001

            

Feedback

1.42

1.17, 1.72

 < 0.001

1.27

0.87, 1.86

0.2

1.38

1.15, 1.65

 < 0.001

1.38

1.16, 1.64

 < 0.001

1.27

0.86, 1.88

0.22

Final mode of interview (Ref: Nurse)

 Interviewer

0.21

0.16, 0.27

 < 0.001

0.19

0.13, 0.26

 < 0.001

      

0.19

0.13, 0.27

 < 0.001

 Web

0.13

0.10, 0.16

 < 0.001

0.11

0.08, 0.16

 < 0.001

      

0.11

0.08, 0.16

 < 0.001

Switcher dummy

0.61

0.46,0.80

 < 0.001

   

0.36

0.27, 0.46

 < 0.001

   

0.62

0.46, 0.81

 < 0.001

Feedback * Final mode of interview

 Feedback * Interviewer

   

1.10

0.68, 1.79

0.7

      

1.10

0.67, 1.80

0.71

 Feedback * Web

   

1.20

0.73, 1.98

0.5

      

1.19

0.71, 1.98

0.51

Age group (Ref: < 30)

 30–50

      

1.32

0.99, 1.77

0.06

   

1.20

0.87, 1.65

0.27

 50–70

      

1.99

1.50, 2.64

 < 0.001

   

2.02

1.49, 2.75

 < 0.001

 70 + 

      

2.03

1.42, 2.92

 < 0.001

   

1.92

1.30, 2.84

0.001

Sex (Ref: Male)

 Female

      

1.11

0.92, 1.32

0.27

   

1.12

0.92, 1.36

0.25

Country (Ref: England)

 Wales

      

0.83

0.55, 1.26

0.39

   

0.98

0.63, 1.51

 > 0.9

 Scotland

      

1.13

0.79, 1.63

0.51

   

1.01

0.68, 1.50

 > 0.9

Highest qualification (Ref: Degree)

 A-level/GCSE

      

0.83

0.68, 1.01

0.06

   

0.76

0.62, 0.94

0.01

 Other/None

      

0.82

0.61, 1.10

0.19

   

0.81

0.59, 1.11

0.19

In paid employment (Ref: Yes)

 No

      

0.93

0.75, 1.16

0.51

   

0.90

0.71, 1.14

0.40

Self-rated health (Ref: Excellent/Good)

 Fair/Poor

      

0.99

0.80, 1.22

0.94

   

0.96

0.76, 1.21

0.72

See NHS last 12 months (Ref: No)

 Yes

      

1.09

0.90, 1.31

0.38

   

1.05

0.86, 1.28

0.65

Time in study (Ref: Original IP1 sample)

 IP4/7/10 refreshment

         

1.02

0.84, 1.24

0.9

1.04

0.84, 1.30

0.70

 IP11 refreshment

         

1.04

0.81, 1.33

0.7

1.01

0.76, 1.33

 > 0.9