Items | Reporting | Journal IFs | Citations | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Studies(n) | Median (IQR) | p-value | Studies(n) | Median (IQR) | p-value | ||
R1.1a | Yes Partly Yes/No | 171 5 | 3.58(2.39,5.55) 3.19(1.56,4.94) | 0.49 | 182 5 | 12(6,26) 12(4.5,15) | 0.458 |
R1.1b | Yes Partly Yes/No | 125 51 | 3.71(2.46,5.52) 3.39(2.28,6.24) | 0.841 | 134 53 | 12 (7,25.25) 12(4,25.5) | 0.493 |
R1.2a | Yes Partly Yes/No | 110 66 | 3.85(2.45,5.56) 3.3(2.35,5.54) | 0.446 | 117 70 | 12(5.5,24.5) 12.5(7,26) | 0.602 |
R1.2b | Yes Partly Yes/No | 88 88 | 3.42(2.3,5.17) 3.79(2.46,6.11) | 0.376 | 97 90 | 10(4.5,24.5) 15(7.75,26.25) | 0.113 |
R1.3 | Yes Partly Yes/No | 33 32 | 4.4(2.65,5.36) 4.65(3.3,8.62) | 0.322 | 33 33 | 10(4.5,30.5) 17(7,39.5) | 0.16 |
R6.1 | Yes Partly Yes/No | 70 106 | 4.11(2.65,5.99) 3.24(2.26,5.22) | 0.04 a | 75 112 | 16(7,32) 10.5(5,19.75) | 0.035 a |
R6.2 | Yes Partly Yes/No | 20 50 | 4.01(3.14,6.13) 4.15(2.38,5.99) | 0.326 | 21 55 | 23(9,60.5) 15.5(6.75,27.25) | 0.088 |
R6.3 | Yes Partly Yes/No | 12 53 | 4.53(3.3,5.66) 4.4(2.9,6.73) | 0.906 | 12 54 | 16.5(4.25,36.5) 13.5(5.75,35) | 0.874 |
R7.1a | Yes Partly Yes/No | 25 151 | 4.07(2.78,6.8) 3.4(2.32,5.48) | 0.116 | 28 159 | 17(9.5,43.75) 11(6,23) | 0.02 a |
R7.1b | Yes Partly Yes/No | 40 136 | 4.15(3.23,6.45) 3.24(2.23,5.49) | 0.014 a | 43 144 | 15(7,41) 11.5(5.25,23) | 0.129 |
R7.1c | Yes Partly Yes/No | 20 156 | 4.58(2.82,12.43) 3.42(2.35,5.42) | 0.036 | 23 164 | 19(12,66) 10.5(5,23) | 0.001 |
R12.1 | Yes Partly Yes/No | 145 31 | 3.94(2.55,5.71) 2.6(1.71,4.4) | 0.004 a | 153 34 | 12(6,27.5) 12.5(5.5,18.75) | 0.534 |
R12.2 | Yes Partly Yes/No | 61 115 | 4.07(2.62,6.21) 3.28(2.32,5.1) | 0.072 | 65 122 | 14(7,29.5) 11(5,23) | 0.276 |
R12.3 | Yes Partly Yes/No | 28 37 | 5.16(3.61,8.46) 4.01(2.64,6.07) | 0.086 | 28 38 | 15(4.25,51.5) 13(5,30) | 0.559 |
R13.1 | Yes Partly Yes/No | 101 75 | 3.95(2.62,5.71) 3.19(2.14,5.49) | 0.119 | 107 80 | 11(5,23) 15(6.25,26) | 0.628 |
R19.1a | Yes Partly Yes/No | 145 31 | 3.75(2.46,5.59) 3.15(1.95,5.49) | 0.133 | 155 32 | 13(7,27) 8.5(3.25,15,75) | 0.01 a |
R19.1b | Yes Partly Yes/No | 54 122 | 4.02(2.59,6.51) 3.47(2.34,5.22) | 0.135 | 58 129 | 15(8,30) 10(5,23) | 0.099 |
R19.1c | Yes Partly Yes/No | 19 51 | 4.07(3.06,5.57) 4.15(2.45,6.29) | 0.751 | 19 56 | 27(9,41) 15.5(6,27.75) | 0.09 |
R19.1d | Yes Partly Yes/No | 112 64 | 3.68(2.42,5.6) 3.39(2.33,5.42) | 0.476 | 118 69 | 15(8,29.25) 9(3.5,18) | 0.001 |
R19.1e | Yes Partly Yes/No | 30 146 | 2.53(1.7,3.77) 3.98(2.55,5.66) | 0.001 | 34 153 | 10.5(7.75,20.75) 12(5,25.5) | 0.855 |
R22.1a | Yes Partly Yes/No | 44 132 | 3.91(2.38,6.45) 3.47(2.41,5.42) | 0.582 | 44 143 | 14.5(7,31.25) 11(6,25) | 0.469 |
R22.1b | Yes Partly Yes/No | 36 140 | 4.64(2.78,6.49) 3.26(2.33,5.19) | 0.022 a | 38 149 | 8(2,18) 14(7,26) | 0.015 a |
R22.1c | Yes Partly Yes/No | 83 93 | 4.4(3.03,6.21) 2.65(1.85,4.43) | <0.001 | 87 100 | 12(6.25,25.75) 12(6,25) | 0.681 |
Total | ≥ 50% < 50% | 65 111 | 4.2(2.97,6.02) 3.17(2.14,5.18) | 0.002 | 72 115 | 16.5(8.25,36.5) 10(5,19) | 0.004 a |