Skip to main content

Table 6 Comparisons of the proposed method in distributed data and corresponding pooled individual-level data analysis

From: Covariate balance-related propensity score weighting in estimating overall hazard ratio with distributed survival data

Distributed Data Analysis

   

Setting 1

  

Setting 2

 
  

Global weight

Local weight

Proposed weight

Global weight

Local weight

Proposed weight

\(K=5\), \({n}_{k}=500\)

Bias

-0.018

-0.014

-0.017

0.045

0.041

0.033

 

RMSE

0.116

0.129

0.106

0.129

0.125

0.110

 

r-RMSE

1.093

1.215

1.000 (Ref)

1.176

1.140

1.000 (Ref)

\(K=5\), \({n}_{k}=1000\)

Bias

-0.006

-0.008

-0.006

0.039

0.024

0.022

 

RMSE

0.089

0.100

0.077

0.096

0.092

0.076

 

r-RMSE

1.160

1.303

1.000 (Ref)

1.269

1.216

1.000 (Ref)

\(K=5\), \({n}_{k}=2000\)

Bias

-0.002

-0.003

-0.001

0.031

0.014

0.011

 

RMSE

0.066

0.065

0.061

0.093

0.094

0.077

 

r-RMSE

1.087

1.071

1.000 (Ref)

1.210

1.223

1.000 (Ref)

Pooled Individual-Level Data Analysis

   

Setting 1

  

Setting 2

 
  

Global weight

Local weight

Proposed weight

Global weight

Local weight

Proposed weight

\(K=5\), \({n}_{k}=500\)

Bias

-0.018

-0.014

-0.017

0.045

0.041

0.033

 

RMSE

0.116

0.129

0.106

0.129

0.125

0.110

 

r-RMSE

1.093

1.215

1.000 (Ref)

1.176

1.140

1.000 (Ref)

\(K=5\), \({n}_{k}=1000\)

Bias

-0.006

-0.008

-0.006

0.039

0.024

0.022

 

RMSE

0.089

0.100

0.077

0.096

0.092

0.076

 

r-RMSE

1.160

1.303

1.000 (Ref)

1.269

1.216

1.000 (Ref)

\(K=5\), \({n}_{k}=2000\)

Bias

-0.002

-0.003

-0.001

0.031

0.014

0.011

 

RMSE

0.066

0.065

0.061

0.093

0.094

0.077

 

r-RMSE

1.087

1.071

1.000 (Ref)

1.210

1.223

1.000 (Ref)

  1. Bias absolute bias, RMSE root mean squared error, r-RMSE ratio of RMSE of global weight or local weight against proposed weight
  2. Setting 1: homogenous design and treatment assignment generated with \({X}_{1}\)~\({X}_{4}\) and \({X}_{1}^{2}\), \({X}_{1}{X}_{4}\); setting 2: heterogeneous design and treatment assignment generated with \({X}_{1}\)~\({X}_{4}\) and \({X}_{1}^{2}\), \({X}_{1}{X}_{4}\)